Cool Old Stuff For Sale online shopping store for beautiful, rare, unusual, and fun vintage collectibles and antiques.
Vintage Collectibles at Cool Old Stuff For Sale
 
Shop Now for Vintage Collectibles Online
Free Shipping on
Orders Over $150

TY BEANIE BABIES

We have hundreds of retired and vintage collector Ty Beanie Babies, most with mint hang and tush tags. These are from 1993-2003, and have never been played with. All Beanies are from a smoke-free environment and have been stored out of the light. These are so much fun and so cute, but it's time to let them go! We have a few Ty Buddies, Teenies and Jingle Beanie Ornaments, which are designated in the listing descriptions.

We will be adding new retired Beanie Babies weekly, so check back often. If you are searching for a particular retired or vintage Ty Beanie Baby from this time frame, please email us using the information on our Contact page. We'll promptly check our inventory and get back to you. Eventually, all items will be viewable online here.

2000 Holiday Teddy the Bear Beanie Baby

2000 Holiday Teddy the Bear Beanie Baby

2000 Retired Ty Seated Beanie Bear with scarf.

$12.00
2003 Holiday Teddy the Bear Beanie Baby

2003 Holiday Teddy the Bear Beanie Baby

2003 Retired Ty Beanie Teddy Bear with Santa hat and scarf.

$15.00
Ally the Alligator Beanie Baby

Ally the Alligator Beanie Baby

1994 Retired Ty Beanie Ally the Alligator with special bonus matching Ally Collector Card! Two items. Fun!

$15.00
Beak the Kiwi Beanie Baby

Beak the Kiwi Beanie Baby

1998 Retired Ty Beanie Tie-Dyed Kiwi Bird.

$9.00
Flaky the Bear Beanie Baby

Flaky the Bear Beanie Baby

2002 Retired Ty Beanie Teddy Bear with snowflakes.

$11.00
Fuzz the Bear Ty Beanie Baby

Fuzz the Bear Ty Beanie Baby

1998 Retired Ty Beanie Teddy Bear in nappy gold fabric.

$12.00
SOLD
Glory the Bear Beanie Baby

Glory the Bear Beanie Baby

1997 Retired Ty Beanie Patriotic Teddy Bear.

$18.00
Goldie the Goldfish Beanie Baby

Goldie the Goldfish Beanie Baby

1994 Retired Ty Beanie orange Goldfish, older and hard to find. We have many other retired Ty Beanie Babies in their own category.

$22.00
Hero (American Arm) the Bear Beanie Baby

Hero (American Arm) the Bear Beanie Baby

2003 Retired Ty Beanie USO Teddy Bear in green, brown and black camouflage with the USA flag on its right arm.

$12.00
Holiday Teddy the Bear Jingle Beanie

Holiday Teddy the Bear Jingle Beanie

1998 Retired Ty Jingle Beanie Teddy Bear Ornament with Christmas holly print.

$9.00
SOLD
Hope the Bear Beanie Baby

Hope the Bear Beanie Baby

1998 Retired Ty Beanie Golden Bear kneeling with hands folded in prayer.

$9.00
Inch the Worm Beanie Baby

Inch the Worm Beanie Baby

1995 Retired Ty Beanie Worm in a rainbow hue with yarn antennae.

$12.00
SOLD
Inky the Octopus Beanie Baby

Inky the Octopus Beanie Baby

1994 Retired Ty Beanie Pink Octopus.

$12.00
Lefty and Righty Pair of Beanie Babies

Lefty and Righty Pair of Beanie Babies

2000 Retired Ty Beanies Righty the Elephant and Lefty the Donkey. Two items. Mint!

$15.00
SOLD
Legs the Frog Beanie Baby

Legs the Frog Beanie Baby

1993 Retired Ty Beanie Frog with long legs for swimming and leaping.

$18.00
Lips the Fish Beanie Baby

Lips the Fish Beanie Baby

1999 Retired Ty Beanie Colorful Fish.

$12.00
SOLD
Lizzy the (Blue) Lizard Beanie Baby

Lizzy the (Blue) Lizard Beanie Baby

1995 Retired Ty Beanie Lizard with blue body and black spots.

$20.00
Lucky the Ladybug Beanie Baby

Lucky the Ladybug Beanie Baby

1995 Retired Ty Ladybug with 11 printed dots.

$30.00
Magic the Dragon Beanie Baby

Magic the Dragon Beanie Baby

1995 Retired Ty Beanie white Dragon with pink wings and hot pink thread.

$18.00
Neon the Seahorse Beanie Baby

Neon the Seahorse Beanie Baby

1999 Retired Ty Beanie Pastel Seahorse.

$10.00
SOLD
Peace the Bear Beanie Baby

Peace the Bear Beanie Baby

1996 Retired Ty Beanie Teddy Bear in a rainbow of colors with peace sign.

$18.00
Princess the Bear Beanie Baby

Princess the Bear Beanie Baby

1997 Retired Ty Beanie Purple Teddy Bear for Princess Diana of England.

$9.00
SOLD
Roxie the Reindeer Holiday Beanie Baby

Roxie the Reindeer Holiday Beanie Baby

2000 Retired Ty Beanie Reindeer with glass eyes and big eyelashes.

$15.00
Scorch the Dragon Beanie Baby

Scorch the Dragon Beanie Baby

1998 Retired Ty Beanie Dragon with metallic wings.

$11.00
Snowball the Snowman Beanie Baby

Snowball the Snowman Beanie Baby

1996 Retired Ty Beanie Snowman

$15.00
Snowgirl Beanie Baby PLUS Snowgirl Jingle Beanie

Snowgirl Beanie Baby PLUS Snowgirl Jingle Beanie

2000 Retired Ty Beanie Snowgirls (two items)

$33.00
Speedy the Turtle Beanie Baby

Speedy the Turtle Beanie Baby

1994 Retired Ty Beanie Turtle, a very early Ty Beanie Baby.

$22.00
SOLD
Swirly the Snail Beanie Baby

Swirly the Snail Beanie Baby

1999 Retired Ty Beanie Snail with a pastel tie-dyed shell.

$11.00
Valentino the Bear Beanie Baby

Valentino the Bear Beanie Baby

1994 Retired Ty Beanie Valentine Teddy Bear.

$20.00
Zero the Penguin Holiday Beanie Baby

Zero the Penguin Holiday Beanie Baby

Adorable 1998 Retired Ty Beanie Penguin in a festive Santa hat.

$9.00

 

Follow Us on Facebook

Email Alerts!
Find out when we add new Cool Old Stuff, get instant coupons, and more! Sign up for our eNews updates: Click to Subscribe

 

Cool Old Stuff For Sale
 
Home About Gift Certificates Sale Items View Cart Contact